A little about me: I grew up in the cradle of civilization. No, not the one between the Tigris and the Euphrates rivers; rather, the one between the Monongahela and Ohio rivers. The tri-state area is Pennsylvania, Ohio, and West Virginia, and we are a breeding ground for professional football players. I’ve seen Joe Montana’s retired football jersey at Ringgold High; my childhood Sundays are associated with visits from Grandma and Dad organizing his duffel bag for the game. My dad has had season tickets to the Steelers since the year I was born, and in that time, has missed maybe a season’s worth of games. My sister and brother both inherited the football gene, which is to say, they were born knowing about “downs” and “holding” and “safety.” They know why they say “hut” and they’ve understood false start since before they went to school.
I was born with the “go into the kitchen and make pizza” gene, which is what my mom had.
Once, during one of my few attempts to understand the game, I asked what they did at the stadium during commercials. My sister laughed until she cried, and then retold my question at numerous family functions, with my dad jumping in and embellishing by imagining people walking out onto the field with “Flic My Bic” signs. They never did tell me what happens during commercials, and it wasn’t until I attended my first pro game in 1999 that I found out what happens: nothing.
So I didn’t get football. Until 2005, when a fellow PA native saw in me the most wonderful kind of tabula rasa, someone who understood the culture and love of the Steelers, but who didn’t understand the game, so he took the entire season to teach me what I didn’t know. By the end of the season, I understand what all the words meant, although I still didn’t understand how everyone in the room but me could jump up simultaneously and yell “HOLDING!” But that was OK. I got football, mostly. And the Steelers won their first Super Bowl since before my brother was born. I cried with joy. My dad cried with me, because he was so thrilled that I finally shared something with him that I had never shared before.
Fast forward five years. With a one-year-old around, we couldn’t get down to Dave’s every Sunday, but I still dressed in my dad’s old Franco Harris jersey during national games. And then we all found out that Big Ben, the slightly dopey yokel who somehow stumbled his way to a Super Bowl victory, was accused–for the second time–of sexual assault. As the details trickled out, people argued whether it was REALLY rape for a 250-pound 28-year-old man to have sex with a blind-drunk 19-year-old in a public bathroom.
I couldn’t have been more disgusted. At worst, he was a straight-up rapist who forced a girl to have sex with him after she’d said no. At best, he was a seriously idiotic asshole who got a girl wasted, had his friends stand guard, and then had sex with her in a public bathroom–all while, no doubt, wearing the prized ring that had made him so famous. I watched friends of mine from high school and college defend his actions on Facebook, vilifying the girl, saying maybe I just didn’t GET that he was a football star, and they’re just treated differently, and that makes it somehow excusable. And besides, she was wasted.
I got wasted in college, I told them. Did I deserve to be sexually assaulted?
Honestly? If he’d been a 22-year-old jackass in the same situation, I might have been willing to shake my head and just be disgusted. But he was 28, which is several years beyond the age of accountability and worlds away from college public-sex behavior. In the end, though, what really infuriated me was not that the charges were dropped, and not that the NFL penalized him with a slap on the wrist, but that the Steelers didn’t drop-kick his ass to the curb the moment any truth was found to the charges.
Why was I so bitterly disappointed? Because for my entire lifetime, I’d known one true thing about the Steelers: they don’t cotton to hiring criminals. They’re not OK with the appearance of evil in their players. They’re Not Like Other Teams. They’re a Family Team. They’ve booted players for having pot in their cars; the fact that they didn’t boot him for sexual misconduct has only one reason at the bottom of it: he makes them lots and lots of money. The only thing that would horrify me more is if I found out that Jim Henson had done what Roethlisberger did.
One of my friends, a lifetime Cowboys fan, put it best with gleeful malice: “Now those sanctimonious Steelers fans have to admit they ALL hire criminals.” Of course. Other teams have dealt–or not dealt–with this for years: murderers, rapists, dopers, dog abusers and cheaters… they’re everywhere. But they weren’t in Pittsburgh.
All last season, I couldn’t watch a single game with any shred of joy. My dad freely said he didn’t care–he just wanted them to win. My sister weighed in that she thought Ben had shown himself to change, and even I grudgingly had to admit that any reports from people seemed to support that.*** But I couldn’t shake my feeling of betrayal: I never understood the game like they did. I never got out of victories what they did. All I’d known for thirty years was the emotional connection to the Steelers, not about winning or what makes them great or anything besides they’re a good team, with mostly good people, and great owners. So I think that had a great deal to do with not shaking the tainted feeling I got every time I saw the offense run out onto the field. Every good play had an asterisk: Good play, but not really.
I skipped the big Super Bowl party, claiming pregnancy as my excuse. I watched the last quarter of the game, and found myself cheering for the Steelers in spite of myself. I was glad the Packers won, but still–I cheered for the Steelers. 35 years of conditioning is hard to overcome.
Last night, the Steelers played the Ravens, a long-time rivalry dating back to when the Ravens were the Browns. Flush with the new space afforded by our Murphy bed, we invited friends over to watch the game. I dressed Gillian in her Steelers sleeper, Eliza in her Steelers hoodie. I wore my Steelers t-shirt. And I felt OK about it. As I cooked a giant pot of Sunday gravy with meatballs, I caught maybe five minutes of the game, and that was OK. The Steelers lost, and that was kind of good, but not satisfying. (We agreed a perfect ending to that game would have been Big Ben and alleged murderer Ray Lewis colliding and causing career-ending injuries to both players.)
Halfway through the game last night, I was keeping the girls occupied in Gillian’s crib, and saw them giggling and playing in their gear, and thought: I can do this. I can live with an asterisk. After all, didn’t I leave the church for awhile in college, avoiding Christmas mass and all things Christmas, and then come back to it when I realized Christmas meant more to me than whether the savior of humanity may or may not have been born that day? I lost one piece of Christmas, but I didn’t have to lose all of it.
From now until Roethlisberger’s exit, Steelers victories will continue to have an asterisk. They’re not the team they purported to be. They’re condoning what is, at best, colossally reprehensible behavior, and at worst, a crime surpassed only by murder. But Heinz Ward isn’t that guy, nor is Troy Polamalu. I can’t bring myself to cheer for him, but I can root for the other guys. I can’t give up a lifetime of family tradition because of the actions of one horrible person, and the act of the people in charge.
A few years back, I attended the August 6, 2007 home Giants game, when everyone was on watch for Barry Bonds’ 756th home run. He didn’t hit it that night, but I remember feeling so thrilled to maybe be able to witness it… but also feeling a little relieved when it didn’t happen. Maybe he won’t hit it after all, I thought. He did, of course–the next night, the bastard–and I was kind of excited to be here for that part of the city’s history. But not really, because he had a big ol’ asterisk in the shape of a needle besides his name, and always will.
When we won the World Series last year, though, without Bonds and his amped-up biceps, his needles and his home runs? THAT was fantastic. And I can look forward to the day when Roethlisberger is gone, and the games are asterisk-less, and we can all wear the black and gold with pride again.
*** My sister Samantha commented on Facebook and the comment didn’t transfer here, so I wanted to give her her say: “I did not say that Ben had definitively changed. I said that I liked to believe that people, including Ben, are capable of changing. That doesn’t make what happened (either the at best or at worst case scenarios) any less stomach-turning. And I still like it better when they win.” I remembered her saying that people around him had testified that he seemed to have changed, and that she believed he was capable of it. I didn’t mean to misrepresent what she said–she was as disgusted with the whole thing as I was!
































